30 N Gould St 63825 Sheridan, WY 82801 Call Us 24/7(607) 225-5002 E-mail Us 24/7info@caremedox.com
Currently viewingMedical Billing Foundations

Lesson 21 - Auto Accident Insurance MB Process

Ad SpaceLesson content ad slot

Definition:

Auto-accident insurance is a contract between insured and insurer (insurance company) that provides protection /coverage to drivers, passengers, and sometimes pedestrians after a car / vehicle crash or cover the financial loss in the event of an accident, theft, natural disaster, or other damage to your vehicle. In return insured paying a regular premiums as per mentioned in policy. It is state level law so minimum requirements are varying from state to state. However, liability coverage is mandate for every state to cover bodily injury and property damage caused by a driver. Also, Auto-Accident coverage is compulsory for anyone who owns or drive a vehicle in every state except New Hampshire state. Driving without the mandatory insurance can lead to penalties such as fines, license suspension, and even jail.

Only New Hampshire is the state where Auto-Accident coverage is not compulsory instead its optional to take with but driver still has to face financial responsibilities due to the cause of damage, people got injure can lead driver to court for their injuries and damage.

Auto-Accident Insurance helps to cover:

  • Property damage (repair/replacement of vehicles, fences, building, etc.).
  • Medical expenses (treatment for injuries).
  • Lost wages (if injuries prevent someone from working).
  • Liability costs (legal responsibility if you cause harm to others).

Auto Accident State Wise Coverage Type:

Auto accident insurance is regulated at the state level, so coverage requirements and billing rules vary from state to state. However, states are generally classified into two main categories:

  1. At Fault (Tort) States
  2. Non Fault (PIP) States

At Fault / Tort States

In these states, the driver who causes the accident is responsible for paying the damages. The injured party typically files a claim against the at-fault driver’s insurance or can sue the at fault driver in case of coverage drops.

All other U.S. states and Washington D.C. follow this at-fault system, including:

Alabama Alaska Arizona
Arkansas Catdfornia Colorado
Connecticut Delaware Georgia
Idaho Iltdnois Indiana
Iowa Louisiana Maine
Maryland Mississippi Missouri
Montana Nebraska Nevada
New Hampshire New Mexico North Carotdna
Ohio Oklahoma Oregon
Rhode Island South Carotdna South Dakota
Tennessee Texas Vermont
Virginia Washington West Virginia
Wisconsin Wyoming Washington D.C.

No Fault / PIP States

In these states, each driver’s own insurance pays for their medical expenses (and sometimes lost wages), regardless of who caused the accident. Lawsuits are limited except in serious injury cases.

Example states:

Florida Hawaii Kansas
Kentucky Massachusetts Michigan
Minnesota New Jersey New York
North Dakota Pennsylvania Utah

Choice No-Fault States:

Kentucky, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania allow drivers to choose between the no-fault system and the traditional tort (fault-based) system when they purchase insurance.

In short, formally majority states follows At fault rules while few states runs non-fault rule

Type of Coverage Benefits

Typically, Auto-Accident insurance policy is a bundle of several types of coverage, some are mandatory while other are optional. Here are the break-down:

Mandatory coverage

  1. Liability coverage:

    Required in nearly every U.S. state, this covers damages you cause to others in an at-fault accident.

    1. Bodily injury liability:

      Pays for the medical expenses of other drivers and their passengers.

    2. Property damage liability:

      Covers damage to another person's vehicle or property, like a fence or building.

  2. Uninsured/underinsured motorist (UM/UIM) coverage:

    Required in many states, this protects you if you are hit by a driver with no insurance or not enough insurance.

  3. Personal injury protection (PIP):

    Required in "no-fault" states, this covers your medical expenses and lost wages, regardless of who is at fault.

  4. Medical payments (MedPay) coverage:

    Similar to PIP but covers only medical expenses. It is required in a few states and optional in others. (Normally used for in At Fault states)

Optional Coverage

  1. Collision coverage:

    Pays for damage to your own vehicle after an accident, regardless of who was at fault. It is often required by lenders if your vehicle is financed.

  2. Comprehensive coverage:

    Covers damage to your vehicle from non-collision events, such as theft, vandalism, fire, or natural disasters. This is also often required for leased or financed cars.

  3. Gap insurance:

    If your financed car is totaled, this covers the difference between your car's actual cash value and the amount you still owe on the loan.

  4. Roadside assistance:

    Pays for emergency services like towing, jump-starts, and flat-tire changes.

How auto insurance works?

When you are involved in a car accident or your vehicle is damaged, you file a claim with your insurance company. How the claim is handled depends on who is at fault and the types of coverage you have.

  1. Reporting the accident:

    You should call the police and report the accident to your insurance company as soon as possible.

  2. Investigation:

    A claims adjuster (representative of the insurance company) is assigned to your case. They will review police reports, interview witnesses, collect evidence, and assess the damage to determine liability and coverage.

  3. Depending on State Law:

    Fault state → at-fault driver’s insurance pays.

    No-fault state → each driver’s own PIP covers medical bills.

  4. Settlement:

    If your claim is approved, the insurer will send a payment for the covered costs, minus your deductible. Costs covered by insurance may be:

    1. Vehicle repair/replacement.
    2. Medical expenses.
    3. Lost wages.
    4. Pain & suffering (in fault states, or serious cases in no-fault states).
  5. If there’s disagreement, the case may go to arbitration, mediation, or even civil court.
Do you know?

Mediator: A neutral referee who guides negotiations to help both sides voluntarily agree on a settlement. They have no authority to force a decision or crown a winner.

Arbitrator: A neutral private judge who reviews evidence and issues a final, legally binding or non-binding ruling to resolve the dispute.

When Mediator or Arbitrator needed or Auto accident dispute / resolution pipeline process?

  • Step 1 (The Rejection): If the injured party refuses the insurance adjuster’s low offer, they pursue further legal action.

  • Step 2 (Mediation): A mediator steps in first to attempt a settlement through structured negotiation.

  • Step 3 (Arbitration): If negotiation fails, an arbitrator reviews the case under either a binding or non-binding framework.

  • Step 4 (The Outcome):
    • If Binding:

      Once the injured party signs the agreement, the arbitrator’s decision is final, legally enforceable, and cannot be appealed—regardless of the outcome.

    • If Non-Binding:

      The injured party can legally reject the arbitrator's decision and take the case directly to civil court to fight for their rights.

Consequences of Driving Uninsured

Legal Penalties:

Driving without insurance can result in significant consequences, including fines, suspension of your driver's license, and possible jail time.

Financial Ruin:

Without insurance, you would be personally responsible for covering all the costs of any damages and injuries in an accident you cause, which can be financially devastating.

How to comply?

Contact Your Insurer:

Work with an insurance company to ensure your policy meets your state's specific legal requirements.

Check State Laws:

Familiarize yourself with your state's auto insurance laws to understand the minimum coverage needed.

Important Notice:
  • Minimum Coverage:

    Each state sets its own minimum liability limits (for example, California requires 15/30/5 = $15,000 per person, $30,000 per accident for injury, $5,000 for property damage).

  • Financed or leased cars:

    Lenders usually require collision & comprehensive coverage in addition to liability.

  • High-risk drivers:

    Some states have assigned-risk pools for drivers who can’t get insurance on the open market.

Does insurance company pays more than what state sets the limit or they finalize the limits in contract?

Direct answer is no, insurance will not pay more than limits set in contract or by state.

Insurance Policy Limits & Payout Realities

  1. Strict Policy Caps: Insurance companies will not pay a single dollar over the contracted policy limit.
  2. The Coverage Gap: For example, California mandates a minimum liability limit of $30,000 per person for bodily injury. If a patient's medical expenses reach $60,000, the at-fault insurance adjuster will only pay out the maximum limit of $30,000.
  3. Pursuing the Remainder: The injured party must pursue the remaining balance ($30,000) from the at-fault driver through mediation, arbitration, or civil court.

Auto Accident Policy Number & Claim Number

An auto insurance company generally assigns one claim number to each injured person for a specific accident. All medical services related to that accident—including office visits, follow-up appointments, diagnostic tests, and therapy—are billed under the same claim number. This is similar to workers' compensation, where one claim number is assigned for each injury incident.

  • Policy Number: Identifies the auto insurance policy and may cover multiple insured drivers or family members.
  • Claim Number: Identifies a specific accident claim for an individual injured person.
Example:
Person Policy Number Claim Number
Driver 1234567 A12345
Passenger 1234567 A12346
Child (same accident) 1234567 A12347
Key Point: A single policy number may cover multiple insured individuals, but each injured person usually receives a separate claim number so that their medical expenses and benefits can be tracked independently.
Major Auto Insurance Carriers

Some of the largest national auto insurers include:

  1. State Farm
  2. GEICO
  3. Progressive
  4. Allstate
  5. USAA (eligible military members, veterans, and their families)
  6. Farmers Insurance
  7. Nationwide
  8. Liberty Mutual
  9. Travelers
  10. American Family Insurance
  11. Erie Insurance (regional)
  12. Auto-Owners Insurance
  13. The Hartford
  14. CSAA (AAA affiliates)
  15. Mercury Insurance (certain states)

Many regional insurers also operate in specific states.

What types of claims are commonly denied?

An insurer may deny or limit payment for reasons such as:

Coverage Issues
  • Policy was inactive on the accident date.
  • Driver was not covered under the policy.
  • Vehicle was not insured under the policy.
Medical issues
  • Treatment was unrelated to the accident.
  • Services were not medically necessary.
  • Records did not support the treatment.
  • Duplicate billing.
  • Experimental or non-covered services.
Policy limitations
  • PIP or MedPay benefits have been exhausted.
  • Required documentation was not submitted.
  • Treatment exceeded state or policy limits.
Exclusions
Examples include:
  • Intentional injury.
  • Racing or other excluded activities.
  • Fraud or misrepresentation.
  • Driving without permission (depending on the policy).
  • Some policies exclude commercial use if the vehicle is insured only for personal use.

Auto Accident Insurance Offered by Employers

Many employers provide auto accident coverage for employees. However, the type of coverage depends on the employer's insurance program and the purpose for which the vehicle is being used. Employer-provided auto insurance generally falls into three categories:

1. Commercial Auto Insurance (Employer-Owned Vehicles)

Commercial Auto Insurance is purchased by businesses to insure vehicles that the company owns, leases, or regularly uses for business purposes, such as delivery vans, company cars, trucks, or service vehicles.

Coverage

If an employee is involved in an accident while driving a covered company vehicle for work, the policy may provide coverage for:

  1. Bodily injury liability
  2. Property damage liability
  3. Collision and comprehensive damage (if purchased)
  4. Medical Payments (MedPay) or Personal Injury Protection (PIP), where included and available under state law
  5. Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) coverage, if purchased
Important Note

Commercial Auto Insurance generally covers accidents that occur within the course and scope of employment. Personal use of a company vehicle may be limited or excluded depending on the employer's policy and the insurance contract.

2. Occupational Accident Insurance (OccAcc)

Occupational Accident Insurance is commonly provided for independent contractors, owner-operators, and gig workers who are not covered by traditional Workers' Compensation.

Coverage

Depending on the policy, Occupational Accident Insurance may provide:

  1. Emergency medical treatment
  2. Hospital expenses
  3. Surgery
  4. Physical therapy
  5. Temporary disability benefits
  6. Permanent disability benefits
  7. Accidental death and dismemberment benefits

Unlike Workers' Compensation, Occupational Accident Insurance usually has fixed policy limits and specific exclusions.

Important Note

Occupational Accident Insurance is not a replacement for Workers' Compensation in every situation and generally does not eliminate an employee's legal rights under applicable law.

3. Hired and Non-Owned Auto (HNOA) Insurance

Hired and Non-Owned Auto (HNOA) Insurance protects an employer when employees use their personal vehicles for company business.

Examples include:
  • Visiting a client
  • Traveling between office locations
  • Purchasing office supplies
  • Banking errands for the company

HNOA primarily protects the employer against liability arising from business use of employees' personal vehicles. Depending on the policy, it may also respond to certain covered claims after other applicable insurance has been considered.

How Claims Are Paid Under HNOA

The order of payment depends on the circumstances of the accident and the applicable insurance policies.

Scenario A – Incidental Business Use

The employee uses a personal vehicle for occasional business purposes, such as:

  • Delivering company documents
  • Purchasing office supplies
  • Traveling to a business meeting

In many cases:

  • The employee's personal auto insurance is the primary insurer.
  • If damages exceed the personal policy limits and HNOA applies, the employer's HNOA policy may provide excess liability coverage, subject to its terms and limits.
Example
Employee's Personal Auto Limit: $50,000
Accident Damages: $120,000
Personal Auto Insurance Pays: $50,000
Remaining Balance: $70,000
If covered, the employer's HNOA policy may pay the remaining liability up to its policy limit.
Scenario B – Commercial Business Use

Some personal auto insurance policies exclude certain commercial activities, such as:

  • Food delivery
  • Package delivery
  • Ride-sharing services
  • Transporting passengers for compensation

    • If the personal insurer denies coverage because of a policy exclusion, the employer's HNOA policy may respond if the loss is covered under the HNOA policy. However, HNOA does not automatically replace the personal policy, and coverage depends on the specific policy language and the facts of the accident.

Coverage After Employment Ends

Employer-provided auto insurance generally ends when employment ends.
However, if an accident occurred while the employee was covered under the employer's policy, that claim normally continues to be handled according to the policy that was in effect on the date of the accident.

Does Employer Auto Insurance Cover Dependents?

Generally, no.
Employer auto insurance is intended to protect the employer and employees while performing authorized business activities. It does not normally extend coverage to an employee's spouse, children, or other dependents for personal driving.

Medical Billing Considerations

When an employee is injured in a motor vehicle accident during work-related travel, the billing staff should first determine:

  • Was the employee driving a company-owned vehicle?
  • Was the employee driving a personal vehicle for company business?
  • Is Commercial Auto Insurance available?
  • Is MedPay or PIP available?
  • Is Workers' Compensation applicable?
  • Does the employee have health insurance?
  • Is an attorney representing the employee?

The answers to these questions determine which insurance should be billed first.

Medical Biller's Quick Guide

Situation Primary Coverage
Employee driving a company-owned vehicle Employer's Commercial Auto Insurance (and other applicable coverage)
Employee using a personal vehicle for routine business Employee's Personal Auto Insurance first; HNOA may provide excess liability coverage if applicable
Employee performing excluded commercial driving (e.g., food or package delivery) Coverage depends on the personal auto policy, the employer's HNOA policy, and the specific facts of the claim
Independent contractor covered by Occupational Accident Insurance Occupational Accident Insurance according to policy benefits
Auto medical benefits exhausted Bill health insurance if permitted under Coordination of Benefits (COB) rules

Comparison with Workers' Compensation

Feature Auto Accident Workers' Compensation
Who provides coverage? Auto insurance company Employer's workers' compensation insurer
Claim number Usually one claim per injured person per accident One claim per workplace injury
Policy number One policy can cover multiple insured drivers, employees or family members Employer has one workers' compensation policy covering eligible employees
Covers dependents? Personal auto policies may cover family members; employer commercial auto policies generally do not No, workers' compensation covers the injured employee (though death benefits may be available to eligible dependents under state law)
Health insurance involvement Often after applicable auto benefits are exhausted or not available or at wait. Only workers' compensation pays for work related injury.

Frequently Asked Questions

When will health insurance pay as secondary?

Health insurance may pay after auto insurance when:

  • PIP/MedPay benefits are exhausted.
  • The auto insurer issues an Explanation of Benefits or denial showing why it did not pay.
  • The health plan allows payment after automobile insurance.

The health insurer generally requires documentation showing what the auto insurer paid or denied.

When can health insurance deny as secondary?

Health insurance may deny payment if:

  • The auto insurer has not processed the claim first

    Many health plans require auto insurance to be billed before they will consider payment.

  • The provider did not follow the health plan's rules

    Examples include:

    • No prior authorization (if required).
    • Out-of-network provider.
    • Untimely claim filing.
    • Missing documentation.
  • The service is not covered by the health plan

    Examples:

    • Experimental treatment.
    • Services excluded by the plan.
    • Treatment not considered medically necessary.
  • The patient's benefits have ended

    Examples:

    • Coverage terminated.
    • Premiums not paid.
    • Waiting period applies.
  • Coordination of Benefits requirements were not met

    If the provider does not submit the auto insurer's payment or denial information, the health insurer may pend or deny the claim until the required information is received.

When does the patient have to pay?

The patient may be responsible for some or all of the remaining balance if:

  • Auto insurance reaches its benefit limit.
  • Health insurance denies the claim for a valid reason.
  • The service is excluded from both policies.
  • The patient has deductibles, copayments, or coinsurance under their health plan.
  • The provider is permitted under applicable law and the insurance contracts to bill the patient for the remaining amount. (In some situations, contracts or state laws may limit or prohibit balance billing.)

Does Auto Accident Insurance covers all types of vehicles?

No, your auto insurance generally will not cover accidents involving a personal vehicle like a bicycle, electric scooter ("VISPA"), or off-road vehicle like a dirt bike unless a registered motor vehicle is also involved. This is because auto insurance is designed for registered, on-road motor vehicles, not for recreational or un-insured vehicles.

Does any state required to buy the auto insurance from state only like worker compensation?

Generally, No.

Drivers usually purchase insurance from private insurance companies licensed in that state.

However, some states have programs to help high-risk drivers obtain coverage when they cannot find insurance in the standard market. These are not usually the only option for all drivers.

Examples include:

  • Assigned Risk Plans
  • Joint Underwriting Associations
  • State-created insurance pools (availability varies by state)

These programs are intended for drivers who cannot obtain insurance through the normal private market.

Click next to continue topic...

Lesson Discussion

Questions and Comments

Ask a question or share feedback for this lesson. Each lesson has its own discussion and comments do not mix between lessons.

No comments yet.

Be the first to ask a question about this lesson.

Your Revenue. Our Responsibility.

Need billing support beyond learning?

From accurate claim submission to consistent follow-ups, CareMedox supports practices with reliable, compliant, and transparent medical billing services.

Start With CareMedox